Male
2005 Logan Mankins, Football
2004 Richie Robnett, Baseball
2003 Nick Watney, Golf
2002 David Carr, Football
2001 Stephen Abas, Wrestling
2000 Courtney Alexander, Basketball
1999 Stephen Abas, Wrestling
1998 Jeff Weaver, Baseball
1997 Giuseppe Chiaramonte, Baseball
1996 Fredrik Bergh, Tennis
1995 Gerry Abas, Wrestling
1994 Trent Dilfer, Football
1993 Lorenzo Neal, Football
1992 Gerell Elliott, Soccer
1991 Bobby Jones, Baseball
1990 Ron Cox, Football
1989 Tom Goodwin, Baseball
1988 Lance Shebelut, Baseball
1987 Doug Fraley, Track
     Kevin Sweeney, Football
1986 Doug Fraley, Track
1985 Doug Fraley, Track
1984 John Hoover, Baseball
1983 Henry Ellard, Football
1982 Rod Higgins, Basketball
1981 Matt Mileham, Track
1980 Tim Norris, Golf
1979 Vince Petrucci, Football
1978 Dean Jones, Football
1977 Steve Campbell, Track
1976 Art Ruble, Swimming
1975 Mike Giroux, Track
1974 Roger George, Track
1973 Mark Hance, Baseball
1972 Jerry Pender, Basketball
1971 Dick Ruthven, Baseball
1970 Erkki Mustakari, Track
1969 Tim McCall, Football
1968 Mike Gallego, Wrestling
1967 Larry Gonsalves, Baseball
     Mike Gallego, Wrestling
1966 Lonnie Hughes, Basketball
1965 Dale Messer, Football
1964 Beau Carter, Football
1963 Eddie Davies, Wrestling
1962 Bobby Paull, Baseball
1961 Dale Messer, Football
1960 Joel Spinola, Golf
1959 Gary Alcorn, Basketball
1958 Ancel Robinson, Track

Women
2005 Jamie Southern, Softball
2004 Jelena Pandzic, Tennis
2003 Chloe Carlotti, Tennis
2002 Jamie Southern, Softball
2001 Becky Witt, Softball
2000 Amanda Scott, Softball
1999 Dora Djilianova, Tennis
1998 Amanda Scott, Softball
1997 Robyn Yorke, Softball
1996 Nina Lindenberg, Softball
1995 Robyn Yorke, Softball
1994 Maureen Brady, Softball
1993 Kim Maher, Softball
1992 Terry Carpenter, Softball
1991 Julie Smith, Softball
1990 Martha Noffsinger, Softball
1989 Yvette Roberts, Basketball
1988 Melanie Parrent, Softball
1987 Gena Strang, Softball
     Wendy Martell, Basketball
1986 Melanie Parrent, Softball
1985 Ruth Lawanson, Volleyball
1984 Renee Wyckiff, Track
1983 Wende Ward, Softball
1982 Wende Ward, Softball